Homeowners win marathon EDPA bylaw fight with Saanich

Saanich council approves removal of three properties from Environmentally Sensitive Areas atlas

Chris and Charmaine Phillips have successfully had the coastal bluff covenant removed from their oceanfront property at the end of Gordon Head Road. The covenant led B.C. Assessment to reduce the value of the property to $1 million in 2016 from $1.7 million in 2015.

Saanich Mayor Richard Atwell considers Tuesday night’s ruling to release three properties from the municipality’s controversial environmentally sensitive areas map a precedent setting move.

Council voted 5-4 in a special session Tuesday to remove the properties of 4007 and 4011 Rainbow St. and 8-1 to remove 4351 Gordon Head Rd. from the ESA atlas. It therefore releases them from the restrictions of the controversial environmental development permit area (EDPA) bylaw that was implemented in 2012.

Couns. Fred Haynes, Susan Brice, Leif Wergeland, Colin Plant and Mayor Atwell voted for the removal of 4007 and 4011 Rainbow St. while Couns. Vic Derman, Judy Brownoff, Vicki Sanders and Dean Murdock were against. Only Derman voted against removing 4351 Gordon Head, standing ground in support of the bylaw and staff’s interpretation of it.

“There’s no coastal bluff ecosystem on the [4351 Gordon Head] property,” said biologist Ted Lea, whose reports successfully supported all three property removals. “If left unattended, the invasives will overrun this property within a few years [or sooner].”

During the debate owner Chris Phillips of 4351 Gordon Head suggested the bylaw has been mis-applied and has instead gone so far astray its become an unintentional tool of land appropriation.

“It’s been three years, but this shows that democracy has worked,” said Phillips, who bought the property with wife Charmaine in 2012. “The [Saanich] biologist report was done to a different standard [than the province] and you cannot just shift the standard overnight. We met the guidelines and jumped every hurdle they asked us to, so they should let us out.”

Plant voted in favour of removing all three properties but didn’t think it necessarily set a precedent as each property will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis. However, Atwell saw it as a landmark case.

“I think it does set a precedent,” Atwell said. “I think we’ll have a number of properties very similar to these, and [other] homeowners will have the expectation that they can come out as well if warranted by the same conditions.”

Other speakers suggested the EDPA bylaw was created on the fly, to which Coun. Judy Brownoff responded it took years and was created by a number of professionals.

Needless to say, there was a divisive set of opinions between residents. Some were pro-EDPA while most were anti-EDPA. The latter cheered and clapped when the properties were removed.

“It’s been a long time coming, we’re very happy the two Rainbow properties are out of the EDPA as they should be,” said Anita Bull, representing her mom, Teresa Bijold (owner of 4007) and uncle Norman Webb (owner of 4011). “We wanted them out because there is no sensitive ecosystem on the properties, they were wrongly mapped, and council agreed on that April 25.”

Couns. Judy Brownoff and Vicki Sanders were on council when the EDPA was implemented and stood against the removal of the Rainbow street properties but did not stand in the way of the 4351 Gordon Head Rd. removal.

“[The EDPA] was not done on the fly, it took years and a number of professionals to develop the bylaw,” Brownoff said. “At the last process there was talk about hardship, [but] I’m not sure there’s a hardship.”

“There’s only a small amount of Garry oak ecosystem left and it’s worth protecting,” Sanders said.

Phillips wasn’t the only speaker to suggest the EDPA is leading to a form of land appropriation by way of restricting the owner’s usage. It didn’t sit well with Vic Derman.

“It’s not appropriate to suggest staff are appropriating land, they’re trying to apply the bylaw,” Derman said.

The property of 4351 Gordon Head had two motions, the first to remove a coastal bluff covenant and the second to discharge it from the EDPA.

The removals are not the first from the EDPA but are the first since it became controversial last year.

“This is a process council embarked on in order to provide some kind of judicial role where staff feel they can no longer make a decision,” Atwell said. “Council can, and does exist as a form of appeal, and in the EDPA we are an appeal process for EDPA relief.

“I think council made the right decision.”

Earlier this spring a pair of legal students at UVic prepared a report that supported the EDPA’s abiltiy.

Just Posted

Saanich police first in B.C. to offer mental health resiliency training

Departments from Oak Bay, Saanich, Central Saanich complete trauma training class

Province launches lawsuit over Esquimalt sailing incident that killed teen with disabilities

Gabriel Pollard, 16, died from injuries after being dropped from marine lift in 2018

Colwood tops Grumpy Taxpayer$ 2019 Candy Cane Awards

Yearly awards for improved governance go to Colwood, Oak Bay, Victoria

North Saanich Fire Department wins national Movember challenge

Team raises more than urban Edmonton, Toronto firefighters

Crash backs up northbound lanes of Pat Bay Highway

Drive BC warns of heavy congestion along busy route

VIDEO: Kenney lays out key demands for meeting with Trudeau

Alberta Premier Jason Kenney aims for clear signs of federal action on two-day Ottawa trip

First Nations want Big Bar landslide cleared ASAP to allow fish passage

Leadership calling for urgent action and resources to remove obstruction on the Fraser

Assessed value of Lower Mainland homes expected to decrease in 2020

Other areas of province may see modest increases over last year’s values

Chilliwack family’s therapy dog injured in hit and run

Miniature pit bull Fifty’s owner is a single mother facing close to $10,000 in vet bills

Cougar destroyed in Penticton area after mauling dog, killing cat

This is the first reported incident with a cougar this year in the Penticton area

Feds not enforcing standards on Hungarian duck imports, B.C. farmer says

‘You have no way of knowing what’s in the bag’

No reports yet of Canadians affected by New Zealand volcano eruption, feds say

Missing and injured included tourists from the U.S., China, Australia, Britain and Malaysia

Vancouver Island blues musician’s mother’s home burglarized and ransacked

David Gogo’s 71-year-old mother has jewelry and artwork stolen in break-in

Dance cancelled after Alberta teacher’s climate lesson prompts online threats

School district near Red Deer cancelled annual family dance due to Facebook comments

Most Read