“Ban horse carriages? Neigh, neigh!” read a protester’s sign outside Victoria City Hall Thursday night.
The protester was one of hundreds who came out to show support for the local horse carriage industry in the face of Victoria Coun. Ben Isitt’s motion to ban the carriages from city streets by 2023 – reinvigorating a debate raised last year after a video surfaced of horses struggling to stand after falling on a Victoria street.
The reaction has been swift, with thousands opposing Isitt’s motion in an online petition and gathering in droves outside City Hall before the evening’s council meeting.
Donna Friedlander, owner of Tally-Ho Carriage Tours, said fighting the motion takes away from her business.
“It’s really scary for us. The motion right now is to review it, but the problem with that is, we’ve just done this nine months ago,” she said. “We just provided all the evidence. We were taken away from operating our businesses last summer significantly, to try to meet the requests of the City, which we did.
Now as we head into our busy season again, it’s just almost impossible for us to continue to juggle things…to keep operating with this black cloud over your head of, ‘do we stay or do we go?”
Asked what might happen to her horses if the ban is approved, Friedlander said she “couldn’t even go there.”
“I can’t even answer that, I don’t know. I’m not independently wealthy, one horse costs about $20,000 a year to upkeep properly,” she said. “I just can’t even go there right now. They’re my family.”
— Nina Grossman (@NinaGrossman) May 24, 2019
Janice Boyes came out from Black Creek to show her support for the horse carriage industry.
“I took my first carriage ride today and I thought it was wonderful,” she said. “I would like to see it continue. It’s as iconic as tea at the Empress.”
Long-time Victoria local Marilyn Williams agreed.
“I’ve lived here for many years and I love them,” she said. “It’s not fair, it’s part of Victoria.”
Coun. Ben Isitt brought the motion to council earlier this month with concerns around the safety of the industry and the impact on the animals.
At least one woman who agreed with him showed up Thursday night.
|Janice Boyes, of Black Creek, stands next to 40-year Victoria resident Marilyn Williams. Both women rallied outside Victoria City Hall Thursday night to show their support for the carriage industry. (Nina Grossman/News Staff)|
Connie Mahoney said the eyes of carriage horses look “empty.”
“Here it’s an industry. People don’t see anything wrong with making money off the backs of animals, even when it’s exploitation,” she said.
“I’m sure everybody here, they love the horses. We all love the horses… we love the elephants in the circus…we love the tigers and the lions whipped and beaten for our entertainment, we love the whales and dolphins in the aquariums, who live their whole lives in confinement.
I see this as the same situation. The same people who say they love them, are not thinking about the animal. I’d like to see them banned tomorrow.”
Kelly Gorman has been driving horse carriages off and on for the last nine years. She said she came out because she cares for the horses.
“We’re the horse nerds, we’re the people that were studying veterinary guides as kids. This [industry] allows us to use our unique skill set in a very practical way,” she said, adding, “I haven’t really had problems in my general operations driving the carriage with the traffic. The horses are quite able to function well in that.”
City of Victoria staff have been asked to report back to council on the work required to phase out the carriages at the next quarterly meeting on Sept. 7.
|A crowd of supports took to Victoria City Hall Thursday night to show support for the local horse carriage industry. (Nina Grossman/News Staff)|