Medical exams for senior drivers irks local driver

Seniors aged 80 and older must deal with receiving 'the letter' from Superintendent of Motor Vehicles

  • Feb. 10, 2015 8:00 p.m.

John McCloud of Sidney holds his recently-renewed drivers' license.

By Travis PatersonBy Angele CowanBlack Press

Bike laws, cell phone distraction and the headache of mandatory medical exams were just a few of the hot topics presented to seniors at Gordon Head United Church on Thursday, when drivers gathered for the latest Connecting Seniors speaking series.

About 50 audience members listened intently as Steve Wallace of Wallace Driving School covered standard driving laws as well as driving concerns specific to seniors in the community.

“I would say cell phone usage in the car is the biggest change we’ve seen,” said Dianne Swanson, who came with husband Wayne.

The two live close to the church and walked to the event, but are life-long drivers.

“There’s a lot to reminded of, such as shoulder checking for bikes,” said Wayne, who’s been driving 55 years.

Neither Wayne nor Dianne have received “the letter,” as Wallace calls it, which mandates drivers aged 80 and older take a driver’s medical examination with a physician. Depending on the results of that exam, drivers may be subject to a road test to retain their license.

North Saanich resident John McLeod received “the letter” from the Superintendent of Motor Vehicles in October, several months before his 80th birthday.

McLeod felt the mandatory form was an invasion of privacy, a violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and age discrimination. He immediately wrote a letter to both Gary Holman, MLA of Saanich North and the Islands, and John Horgan, leader of the B.C. NDP.

“My contention is it’s an invasion of privacy and a discrimination of an identifiable group,” said McLeod. “And it’s in violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, that you’re innocent until proven guilty. They’re assuming you’re guilty of being incapable to drive, but that’s assuming that everybody at a certain age has a medical condition.”

McLeod asserts that seniors are the most law-abiding demographic, and that there are far worse dangers on the road than elderly drivers.

“Whenever there’s a senior in an accident, (the public) blows it up. But if there’s a drunk driver, you hardly ever hear of it,” he said. “They never say to drunk drivers, ‘Unless you join AA and prove that you don’t drink and drive, you can’t have your license.’ They would never put them through the process that they did when I turned 80.”

It’s nothing new that motor vehicles department, which falls under the Ministry of Justice, has targeted seniors and youths, Wallace said.

“It’s my guess that government policy is looking at a graduated de-licensing for seniors, just the same as there’s a graduated licensing for youth, the two demographics with a disproportionately high number of crashes.”

According to a spokesperson from the Ministry of Justice, the province has been screening aging drivers for potentially dangerous medical conditions since at least 1975, when drivers were required to start submitting medical reports at age 70.

Currently in B.C., the forms are mandatory for drivers who turn 80 and every two years thereafter, as well as drivers who have commercial licenses, drivers with a known medical condition or drivers who are reported as having a medical condition that may make it unsafe for them to drive.

As for McLeod, he ended up filling out the form, but made little head way in his drive for justice.

“But it cost me $125. The cost is borne by the senior, and as a senior, it’s tough luck,” he said.

“(Seniors) have contributed more than any other group to society, and we should be treated with more respect.”

Wallace, in his driving presentation, reminded seniors that the driver’s test is more of a checking test.

“When you get ‘the letter’ and you go to the doctor, you need your driver’s abstract, proof of your insurance (and discount), an assessment from a driving instructor and a some evidence that you’ve practised cognitive exercises.”

Once such place is, which offers a free trial of its brain games.

“It shows you’re assertive and puts the doctor in a place of comfort,” he said.

Just Posted

Saanich adopts new four-year strategic plan featuring five goal areas

‘Living document’ to be revisited throughout the year

Work begins on Admirals Bridge to install wastewater pipe, possible traffic changes

Construction will take approximately six to eight weeks to complete

A white Christmas not likely for Greater Victoria

Snow could be in the forecast for mid to late January, early February, says meteorologist

Sno’uyutth Day event cancelled

Organizers focused on ‘spreading good energy’ throughout the coming year

POLL: Do you plan on making any purchases on Black Friday?

We’ve all seen the images. Shoppers rioting outside of a store in… Continue reading

Members of little people community applaud change to drop ‘midget’ term

‘It’s not about sensitivity,’ says Allan Redford, the president of the Little People of Canada

Little progress in preventing sudden infant deaths since last report: BC Coroner

Coroners panel studied 141 sleep-related sudden infant deaths between 2013 and 2018

Dive team searching for missing Cowichan fisherman

Bill Court said family and friends are actively engaged in the search

B.C.’s ‘Dr. Frankenstein of guns’ back in jail yet again for trafficking in Glock parts

Bradley Michael Friesen has parole revoked for allegedly importing gun parts yet again

B.C. woman suing after laser hair removal leaves her with ‘severe’ burns, scarring

Nadeau felt ‘far more pain’ than usual during the treatment

$2.9 million judgment in B.C. blueberry farm sabotage lawsuit

The new owners saw most of their farm ruined just as they took possession

B.C. to more than double sales tax on vaping products

Tax up from 7 to 20 per cent, tobacco tax up two cents

Most Read