Saanich council sounds off on election sign debate

Plans by Coun. Colin Plant to end ‘sign wars’ receive support but also push-back

Plans by Coun. Colin Plant to reduce election signage received general support from his colleagues, but also some criticism.

Plans presented Monday would limit the size and number of signs displayed on Saanich public property, while still allowing private property owners to display larger signs. The proposals — which staff will now review — also aim to align municipal with provincial regulations around displaying election signs.

RELATED: Saanich councillor wants to stop ‘sign wars’ of past municipal elections

Coun. Ned Taylor said he generally favours measures proposed by Plant to reduce the number of election signs but warned of unintended consequences.

“I’m happy to see this come forward,” he said. “Overall, I think there were too many election signs. I think it would be ideal to have less. However, I think we have to be very careful about how we go about this.” Taylor said election signs were his primary tool for promoting his candidacy. “Honestly, I’m not sure, if I would have been able to do that, if I weren’t able to use signs,” he said. “So it was a huge asset for me, not only as a new candidate, but as a young candidate, who may be doesn’t have as many connections in the community as an incumbent or an older demographic may have.”

Incumbents have the advantage of name recognition and may not need as many signs as non-incumbents, he said. “So I don’t want this council to introduce policy that makes it more difficult for new candidates to get elected.”

Elections signs, he said, also alert the public to elections themselves. “Low voter turn-out is a big issue which we deal with at the municipal level and one of the benefits of having signs is showing people that elections are happening,” he said.

Coun. Zac de Vries echoed Taylor’s criticisms. Signs represent a “very effective and necessary tool” for candidates, especially younger ones, to get their names out, he said.

Coun. Rebecca Mersereau said she “is very supportive” of efforts to reduce the number of election signs for aesthetic, environmental and safety reasons among others, including the need to level the playing field between incumbents and non-incumbents, as well candidates with means and those without.

“I think it is important for us to recognize that any rules that increase the relative importance of signs on private property will inherently advantage older candidates, who are more likely to have property owners amongst their social networks,” she said. “That is a very important consideration in this region, with high housing costs.”

Mersereau said she is also worried about the costs of administering the rules concerning election signs. That needs to be an important lens through which the municipality needs to consider any future changes, she said, adding that she would support staff offer a more “holistic” set of policies.

Responding to the concerns, Plant welcomed the discussion, adding nothing in his proposals aims to undermine younger candidates. Plant said his proposals generally aim to level the playing field when it comes to using Saanich’s public land

RELATED: Saanich municipal candidate plays politics by a different tune

“That is where it is prudent to limit how many [signs] there are,” he said. “Nobody is suggesting that we are removing them by any stretch. Let’s us make that super-clear.”

If Saanich, by way of example, were to identify 50 public locations were signs were permissible, candidates would have 50 signs each, he said. “That would be fair and equal,” he said. “It may not be fair that someone of us have access to people, who own private lands. I acknowledge that.”

But that issue lies outside council’s responsibility, he said. “The fact that I know 20 land-owners, who own houses, that is a societal inequity. But I don’t think we should prevent them from having a sign on their property,” said Plant, adding that he looks forward to seeing staff’s review.

Plant received support from Coun. Judy Brownoff, who said that limiting the number of signs could actually level the financial playing field, as well as members of the public. She also agreed with plans to better coordinate with provincial authorities concerning the permissible locations and duration of election signage.


Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

wolfgang.depner@saanichnews.com

Just Posted

Oak Bay plants new program for National Tree Day

Tree canopy grows from final wishes of community association founder

Bear shot with crossbow arrow believed dead

BC Conservation, police track injured black bear’s blood trail near Lost Lake Road

Bank robber targets Langford RBC

RCMP say robber produced a note, left with cash

VIDEO: Grizzly bears fight along northern B.C. highway in rare footage

Cari McGillivray posted the head-turning video, shot near Stewart, B.C., to social media

Pettersson has 4 points as Canucks dump Ottawa 6-4

Vancouver wins NHL pre-season tilt in Abbotsford

British man returns to Yukon to tipple his own toe in long-running tradition

So-called sourtoe cocktail is a shot of whisky with a mummified human toe in it

Poll suggests Canadians concerned about fake news, but struggle to spot it

56 per cent of respondents admitted to reading or sharing inaccurate news

Province announces $3.5 million in funding for community solutions to overdose crisis

Grants up to $50,000 will be available for municipalities working with a regional health authority

Conservatives’ plan to ease mortgage stress-test rules may raise debt and prices

Andrew Scheer vows to loosen rules around stress test and remove it altogether for mortgage renewals

B.C. mom urges patience after rude comments while out with toddlers

People asked to be better and to help each other

U.S. wrestler says viral speeding ticket video was staged

WWE wrestler Lacey Evans says she does not condone disrespecting law enforcement officers

‘Own a piece of history’: Beachcombers location Molly’s Reach up for sale

‘This is one of B.C.’s most photographed buildings’

Most Read