Wrongful use of spyware was a ‘corporate decision,’ says Saanich CAO

Consultant finds 'no evidence of malfeasance' after Saanich CAO Andy Laidlaw delivers in-house report

An in-house report released Wednesday on the use of spyware at the District of Saanich admits senior staff failed to consider privacy concerns, but stops short of blaming any individual staff member for its improper use.

The report, completed by interim CAO Andy Laidlaw, used findings from Brian Simmons, a contracted labour relations consultant, to answer questions put forward by Saanich council about the use of Spector 360, an employee monitoring tool.

The software was covertly installed on the computer of Mayor Richard Atwell and on 12 other workstations at the District on Dec. 2, 2014 and was disabled on Jan. 21 after B.C.’s privacy commissioner launched an investigation into its use.

Simmons concluded that there was no evidence to “support a claim that Atwell’s computer was targeted” by the employee monitoring software, and said he found “no evidence that would single out any particular individual in this matter, rather it was a corporate decision.

“Finding no evidence of malfeasance, I find no cause to terminate or discipline any employee,” Simmons wrote in his June 20 report.

Privacy Commissioner Elizabeth Denham released a scathing report into the District’s improper use of Spector 360 on March 30, in which she said senior staff failed to consider privacy standards before approving its use. Denham also found senior staff failed to notify Atwell about the software’s installation on his computer, and noted “the District’s submissions to my office demonstrate a deep lack of understanding about the most basic tenets of the (Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy) Act, such as what constitutes the collection of personal information.”

Denham also concluded that Director of Corporate Services, Laura Ciarniello, gave the express approval to install the spyware.

In a statement, Laidlaw said his report is intended to bring closure to the spyware scandal for both council and staff.

“Decisions were made by the senior management in the best interests of protecting Saanich’s information and technology system,” Laidlaw said.

“The implementation lacked a review through the lens of (the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act) because the software was being viewed purely as an additional security installation.”

Laidlaw agreed that Denham was right when she called out the municipality for failing to complete a “privacy impact assessment,” which should have led senior staff to reconsider Spector 360’s invasive functions like keystroke logging and screenshot recordings.

“In my opinion, there was a systemic disconnect within the organization on the issue of personal privacy,” Laidlaw said.

“I recognize that Council has a need for accountability, however, it would be simplistic and inaccurate to point to some decision or event.”

The internal report also reveals five IT staff resigned and one retired between December 2014 and May 2015.

More to come.


Just Posted

PHOTOS: Thousands show for 40th GoodLife Marathon in downtown Victoria

New records, first-time runners, and stories of resilience

Mother of alleged hit-and-run victim hopes municipalities will work together to improve crosswalk

Young woman injured, dog killed when struck by driver on marked crosswalk at Foul Bay Road

Here comes the rain: Victoria can expect post Thanksgiving showers all week

Mild, rainy weather expected from Tuesday to Saturday

Opponents of Elizabeth May criticize her push to scrap temporary foreign worker program

May has proposed to scrap the federal program which supplies local business with temporary workers

Victoria woman uses loss to raise awareness of Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Day

City of Victoria to recognize Pregnancy and Infant Loss Awareness Day Oct. 15

VIDEO: Greater Victoria, here’s the news you missed this weekend

Dog killed in alleged hit and run, Goodlife Marathon takes over city and more

Canadian Snowbirds plane crashes before air show in Atlanta

Pilot lands safely after ejecting from jet

Share crash data, private insurers tell David Eby, ICBC

B.C. monopoly makes drivers retrieve their own records

B.C. VIEWS: Wolf kill, not backcountry bans, saving caribou

B.C.’s largest herds turn the corner from extinction

Pearson nets shootout winner as Canucks clip Flyers 3-2

Vancouver picks up second straight home win

Map on Elections Canada website sends Nanaimo-Ladysmith voters to landfill

Address for polling station correct, but Google Map address differs

BC Children’s Hospital launches 2 new virtual care sites bringing total to 19 across province

Provincial initiative allows pediatric patients to see health specialists through video

‘Wham-bam out the door’: Surrey man’s front yard left ruined by scamming landscaper

Resident warns neighbours to be careful of door-to-door salesmen

Most Read