LETTER: Dam impact exagerated

Art Bickerton claims in his letter to the editor that 31,000 acres of farmland will be flooded by the narrow reservoir behind the Site C dam.

Yet James D. Anderson, a person very familiar with the narrow valley and farmland there, is in print stating that only 4,000 acres with actual agricultural potential will be flooded – of which only 1,000 is under cultivation today and that only for animal food.

A possible source of error is incompetent reading of a report by the University of Northern B.C. Researchers attempted an analysis of the amount of farmland to be flooded but basic checking of reality showed their analysis was very wrong – yet they didn’t have money left to figure out why. Their report clearly states that the value from the analysis is wrong, yet some eco-activists quote the erroneous amount. Note the river canyon is narrow in that area.

The campaign by eco-activists against the Site C dam is strange, given that hydro-electric power comes from a renewable source called precipitation (though eco-activists disingenuously claim it is not) whereas alternatives like solar and wind are a very small proportion of actual generation, will remain so due to the area of installations required to meet demand and their cost, and need expensive storage systems to provide electricity when the sun isn’t shining and the wind isn’t blowing.

PS: Bickerton says the Mica dam project flooded 8,000 square miles of forest and farmland – the 31,000 acres claimed by Bickerton for Site C farmland only is 48 square miles. (640 acres per square mile, 2.47 acres per hectare, rounding applied]

Keith Sketchley


Just Posted

Elizabeth May arrested at Kinder Morgan protest

Randall Garrison, MP for Esquimalt-Saanich-Sooke, speaks out against pipeline

Large Kinder Morgan pipeline protest at Victoria MP office

Dozens gathered out front of Murray Rankin’s constituency office Friday to protest Trans Mountain pipeline

Esquimalt High robotics students engineer their way to Texas

Rookie team qualifies for FIRST World Championship after breathing life into armed robot Spike

5 must-do things this weekend in Greater Victoria

Soccer playoffs, hockey playoffs, Dunahee run, art show and Lego

Capital Region regular gas prices highest since 2008

Greater Victoria prices roughly 10 cents above the B.C. average

Vancouver Island’s Best Videos of the Week

A look at some of the best video stories from the past week ending March 23, 2018

Canucks sing the Blues as they fall to St. Louis 4-1

Berglund nets two, including the game-winner, to lift St. Louis over Vancouver

Calving season brings hope for Cariboo ranchers

Still a lot of work ahead to recover from the wildfires

Canada’s Kaetlyn Osmond wins figure skating world title

The 22-year-old fwon the women’s singles crown with her Black Swan routine

Vancouver Island pooches celebrate National Puppy Day

Check out some of the submissions we received from around the region

MLA Report: Lowering the voting age to 16 in BC

By Andrew Weaver On March 13, I introduced for a third time… Continue reading

Alberta tells B.C. to stop opposing pipelines if it doesn’t like gas prices

John Horgan said he would like to see the federal government step in to deal with high gas prices.

View Royal mayor says Saanich had a take-it-or-leave-it approach to fire dispatch

Re: Communities pull the plug on Saanich fire dispatch. Mayor Richard Atwell… Continue reading

B.C. mother hit in truck rampage dies

Family confirms mother of four Kelly Sandoval dies almost two months after being hit.

Most Read