Our relationship with animals needs year 1800 thinking

Re: Don’t feel too sorry for Fido (Our View, June 13)

Re: Don’t feel too sorry for Fido (Our View, June 13)

Recently this paper published an editorial arguing that we should rein in our concern for non-human animals, and deer in particular. “We are the superior species,” the writer proclaimed, “and as such we must make decisions based on what is best for us, even if that means our four-legged friends miss the picnic.” But in what sense are humans superior?

The Great Chain of Being, which placed humans above all other earthly creatures, was developed in the third century based on philosopher Plato’s teachings.

Modern biology has proven otherwise. Life is a tree, not a hierarchy.  Each living species occupies the end of one of its 8.7 million branches. None of the branches is superior to the rest in any objective sense.

It might be noted that we can reason and use language, unlike any other species. Doesn’t this prove our superiority?

Remember, not all people can do these things. Some people’s capacity to reason or speak is severely compromised due to age, illness, or disability, but this does not give us licence to ignore their interests. So we cannot pin our superiority to our reasoning or linguistic abilities, unless we are prepared to deny equal status to many of our fellow humans.

As Jeremy Bentham wrote more than 200 years ago: “The question is not, can they reason? Nor, can they talk? But can they suffer?” It’s time we heed Bentham’s advice, and expand our circle of concern towards all sentient creatures.

Akim McMath





Just Posted

Victoria resident catches, cleans pigeon feet to help fight stringfoot

Hair, string tangled around birds’ feet can cut off circulation to toes and whole feet

Cyclists rejoice as the Christmas Lights Parade returns

Family-friendly 10km ride visits big Christmas displays, Dec. 21

Victoria residents advocate for funding for neighborhoods without community centres

North Park Neighbourhood Association hopes to see $75,000 to bolster nearby staff

Victoria resident faces discrimination from BC Transit since transitioning to a wheelchair

Daniel Sands says they are often not allowed on buses, even when there is room

VIDEO: These are the top toys this Christmas, B.C. toy experts say

Consider the play value of a game, staff at Toy Traders say

Mayor wants B.C. to institutionalize severely mental ill people who are homeless

Those suffering from mental health conditions, such as schizophrenia, need specialized care, mayor says

Five things of note from Trudeau’s mandate letters to his ministers

Some marching orders come from the Liberal Party’s campaign, while others are new additions

Scheer’s resignation tips party into internal war over school tuition payments

The Conservatives have a Toronto convention already scheduled for April

POLL: Do you have a real or artificial Christmas tree?

The lights are up, holiday shoppers are bustling through the streets and… Continue reading

Navigating ‘fever phobia’: B.C. doctor gives tips on when a sick kid should get to the ER

Any temperature above 38 C is considered a fever, but not all cases warrant a trip to the hospital

Transportation Safety Board finishes work at B.C. plane crash site, investigation continues

Transport Canada provides information bulletin, family of victim releases statement

Wagon wheels can now be any size! B.C. community scraps 52 obsolete bylaws

They include an old bylaw regulating public morals

Suspect steals 150 pairs of cosmetic contacts from Nanaimo party supply store

Incident happened at Pattie’s Party Palace on Rutherford Road on Thursday

Most Read