Term ‘nanny state’ used to reject potential solutions to problems

It can be seen that some relief from the pressures of both income and environment do not lead to indolence

Mr. Fletcher wields the term “nanny state” as an epithet, where he lets his ideology override facts readily available with a soupçon of research.

There are two excellent articles “out there” that just may help bring some light into the dark corner Mr. Fletcher apparently wallows in.  One is by Dr. Evelyn L. Forget, University of Manitoba, who analyzed the results of a guaranteed income experiment (dubbed “mincome”) conducted in the town of Dauphin, Man. in the 1970s.

Her conclusion found in part “… that only new mothers and teenagers worked substantially less. Mothers with newborns stopped working because they wanted to stay at home longer with their babies, and teenagers worked less because they weren’t under as much pressure to support their families, which resulted in more teenagers graduating. In addition, those who continued to work were given more opportunities to choose what type of work they did. (Dr.) Forget found that in the period that Mincome was administered, hospital visits dropped 8.5 per cent, with fewer incidents of work-related injuries, and fewer emergency room visits from accidents and injuries.”

A second study, this one about drug use and addictions, was conducted by Bruce Alexander a psychologist (retired) from Simon Fraser University, who “…ran a series of …… experiments he calls Rat Park, which led him to conclude that drugs — even such hard drugs as heroin and cocaine — do not cause addiction; the user’s environment does.”

His research revealed, among many other things that “…there are the thousands of American soldiers who became heroin addicts during the Vietnam War. In an unrivalled demonstration of the effect of setting, a 1975 survey found that 88 per cent of them simply stopped using the drug when they left the war zone.”  They left a dangerous environment for the relatively far safer one of home – and quit being dependent on the drug.

In putting these two findings together, it can be seen that some relief from the pressures of both income and environment do not lead to indolence in the vast majority of instances, but to greater productivity and decreased drain on support services, such as detox programs and hospital visits.

It would do Mr. Fletcher a world of good (not unlike the Grinch at Christmas) to see that his so-called “nanny state”, and the efforts of the B.C. government to address homelessness by providing at least part of what the above research has shown that works, is a step in the right direction.

Richard Weatherill



Just Posted

Saanich resident leads crusade against cigarettes in B.C. drugstores

Province allows drugstores to sell cigarettes and some feel policy should change, retailers disagree

Saanich councillor fears weed could crowd out food as greenhouses convert

Head of provincial association representing greenhouse vegetable farmers not worried about issue

PHOTOS: India Mela celebrates culture, dance and food

The annual downtown event brought culture and fun together

Residential construction activity slows across Greater Victoria

Vancouver Island Construction Association warns of ‘mixed outlook’

VICTORIA FRINGE FEST: There’s always something new to discover on stage

33rd annual live theatre festival has numerous styles and topics to choose from

Bodies of two missing Surrey men found near Ashcroft: RCMP

Ryan Provencher and Richard Scurr have been missing since July 17

Hearings begin as Vancouver Island mom fights for allegedly abducted daughter

Tasha Brown now in Jersey in the British Isles, fundraiser being held in Nanaimo

B.C. manhunt suspects left cellphone video before they died: family

Family member says Kam McLeod, Bryer Schmegelsky recorded final wishes

VIDEO: RCMP unveil new, state-of-the-art forensics lab in Surrey

The laboratory is expected to handle thousands of forensic services from across Canada annually

Scheer promises EI tax credit for new parents if Conservatives form government

The government currently taxes employment insurance benefits for new parents

B.C. seizes 1.5M grams contraband tobacco, down from 5.75M grams the year prior

The 2019-2020 seizures were a sharp drop compared to the 2018-2019 year,

B.C. Speaker tight-lipped about aide’s legislature security tour

B.C. Liberals question Alan Mullen’s drive across Canada, U.S.

B.C. sets rules for ride hailing, same minimum fee as taxis

Larger operating areas seen as threat by cab companies

Most Read