Sisters 4-year-old Aubrey Berry and 6-year-old Chloe Berry were found dead in their father’s apartment in Oak Bay on Christmas Day. Their father Andrew Berry is charged with two counts of second-degree murder in their deaths. (Submitted photo) Sisters 4-year-old Aubrey Berry and 6-year-old Chloe Berry were found dead in their father’s apartment in Oak Bay on Christmas Day 2017. Their father Andrew Berry is charged with two counts of second-degree murder in their deaths. (Family photos)

UPDATED: Oak Bay father takes stand, denies killing young daughters

Andrew Berry has plead not guilty to the December 2017 deaths of his two daughters

*Warning: This story contains disturbing content about a double murder trial.

At times emotional, at other times barely audible, 45-year-old Andrew Berry took the stand in his own defence in the Vancouver Law Courts Wednesday morning.

“Mr. Berry, did you kill Aubrey and Chloe?” asked defence lawyer Kevin McCullough.

“No, I did not,” Berry answered quietly.

“On December 25, did you try to commit suicide?”

“No, I did not.”

In Victoria, among those packed into the sixth floor courtroom where the trial is broadcast live was Sarah Cotton, mother of the two girls, watching the proceedings surrounded by family and friends.

Berry is accused of murdering his daughters, six-year-old Chloe and four-year-old Aubrey at his Oak Bay apartment on Christmas Day, 2017. He is the defence counsel’s first witness after months of the Crown’s case, which saw law enforcement, first responders, blood spatter experts, family, friends, neighbours and acquaintances take the stand.

Read more about this trial and case

After his opening statements, McCullough asked Berry what kind of child Chloe had been and Berry, clean-shaven in a white and pale blue checked shirt with his hair parted neatly to one side, spoke quietly into the microphone.

“She was gregarious, outgoing. She would talk to anybody,” Berry’s voice broke with emotion and he paused. “She would talk to all kinds of people, no matter what they looked like. She wasn’t shy.”

It was the first of Berry’s many emotional outbursts when asked about the young girls on Wednesday. But answering questions about his gambling problem – winning, losing and borrowing sometimes thousands of dollars a week – seemed to come much easier.

Berry testified that he started gambling when he worked as a bellboy at Sutton Place – a downtown Vancouver hotel where he made up to $200 in cash each shift. He started playing baccarat – a comparative card game where players can bet on two hands, trying to get to a nine.

As he moved from job to job over the years – working as a trust accountant, market researcher and economist – his gambling habit persisted. Whether it was sports betting or baccarat, Berry was frequently borrowing money to support his habit. But he testified that at that time, he always paid those debts back.

A job at BC Ferries – based in a downtown Victoria office – connected Berry with Cotton. They started dating in February, 2009 and moved in together the next year. During his relationship with Cotton, Berry said his gambling slowed.

After having both girls, the relationship began to fall apart. The two split in 2013. And after a case in family court, Berry was granted 40 per cent custody of the girls. He and Cotton attempted a co-parenting relationship.

Berry said his gambling picked up again. He was spending roughly $3,000 a month on sports betting and began going to the casino more regularly.

In Fall, 2015 he won just under $100,000 from a complicated sports bet. A few days later he withdrew about $87,000 and within months had gambled away most of his earnings. Berry said after losing the $10,00 he has left in a baccarat game at the River Rock Casino, he borrowed $10,000 from a man named Paul.

He testified that he had known Paul from gambling back in Vancouver and described him as a Chinese man in his 50s. Berry quickly lost the $10,000 he borrowed and said the debt he owed Paul snowballed, collecting interest as he continued losing more and more money, unable to pay back his debt by agreed-upon dates.

He said by spring, 2017 he owed Paul $25,000 and had decided that he would pay the debt using his pension. But after quitting his job with BC Ferries to gain access to the money, he learned it would take longer than he thought to get the money.

This time, when Berry asked Paul for an extension, he said there was a caveat – he had to store a “bag” in his apartment.

“I wouldn’t have to do anything, I wouldn’t have to see it, I wouldn’t have to touch it,” Berry testified.

When McCullough asked him what he thought it might be, Berry said common sense told him it was something illegal. Specifically, he said he thought it was drugs.

Berry testified that in March, two young Chinese men – one with a sleeve of tattoos – came to his apartment and hid a bag in the top shelf of his closet. He claimed he never touched it or looked at it, and it was picked up again in April.

Over the following months Berry was able to scrounge together some money – some from his pension and some from gambling – but it was always too little, too late. The money was considered interest and the $25,000 debt was still owed. Berry claimed that when Paul asked him to hold another bag at his apartment, he said yes, but this time had to hand over his keys.

He said when Paul asked to take a picture of his licence – which had an incorrect address – Berry voluntarily told Paul his real, Beach Drive address, in order “to be honest.”

He claimed that he did not see or hear from Paul or the other men between the second bag drop in November and Christmas Day, 2017.

Berry told the court that after his arrest he requested to be put in protective custody in order to protect himself from Paul.

Berry’s testimony continues Thursday.



nina.grossman@blackpress.ca

Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter

Just Posted

PHOTOS: Saanich Fire Department celebrates 100th anniversary with birthday party

Attendees were treated to pizza, truck tours and cake

It’s the first day of fall: seasonal events abound in Greater Victoria

Pumpkins, cider, Halloween and more coming to the region

CRD warns of possible injured bear in Thetis Lake area

Do not approach, keep safe distance

Students and teachers to unite in Monday’s climate action rally

A teach-in for climate justice is set to take place at the B.C. Legislature this afternoon

Regional mixer reveals more about new federal export office coming to Greater Victoria

Third Annual Five Chamber Mixer offered chance to learn more about new federal export office

VIDEO: Grizzly bears fight along northern B.C. highway in rare footage

Cari McGillivray posted the head-turning video, shot near Stewart, B.C., to social media

‘This is savage’: Strip club owner suspects arson in Williams Lake fire

Investigators on scene to determine cause of fire that destroyed at least two businesses

B.C. VIEWS: School officials join fact-free ‘climate strike’

Students, public get distorted picture of greenhouse gases

Judge rules cops did not coerce statement from B.C. man accused of assaulting sex worker

Defence wanted Vernon’s Curtis Sagmoen’s video interview with police deemed inadmissible

GRAPHIC: Tortured cat found with string around its neck in Kelowna alleyway

City crews have been contacted and are on the way to pick up the dead feline.

Firefighters may be needed for paramedic apartment access, experts say

Better coordination recommended in urban B.C. 9-1-1 calls

Hundreds of thousands stranded as travel agency collapses

British tour company Thomas Cook brought down by a variety of factors

B.C. police chief to speak to Liberal candidate after second ad appears featuring photo of officer

Jati Sidhu had said an ad with the same photo posted last Friday was ‘not appropriate’

Tour de Rock ride kicks off in the North Island

I would ride all day in the rain if it means raising money to help these kids”

Most Read