Environmental bylaw costly for Saanich property owners

There is clear indication that several Saanich property owners have lost value in the sale of their properties

Re: Saanich begins review of environmental development bylaw, Oct 12. We are the owners of 4351 Gordon Head Rd., that was referenced in the above-mentioned article.

We would like to take this opportunity to highlight some overlooked points as there continues to be misinformation about property values in the EDPA, which your article appears to perpetuate.

In fact, information on this very subject was gathered from several sources over a period of several months for the much-anticipated Rollo report, which was to have been released in March of this year, and the release of which has been delayed over and over again. Many of us are suspicious the municipality was disingenuous with the introduction of the bylaw and heavy handed in its implementation and support of the bylaw.

Also, articles from 2015 clearly point to other property owners having lost value in the sale of their properties, in spite of a very hot real estate market.

An article in the Saanich News in May 2015 reported that a landowner was having difficulty selling two lots, due to Saanich placing a protective covenant on 60 per cent of their lots. This in spite of the area that was covenanted being described as completely covered by invasive species.

They subsequently indicated that they had lost approximately $100,000 per lot, when they were finally sold. In yet another story reported from 2015 regarding a property owner on Burnside Road, who owned two one-acre lots, both of which had 80 per cent of the property in the EDPA, again dominated by invasive species, as was the adjacent area of Knockan Hill Park. In spite of there being no covenant on this property, one of these properties sold for about $250,000 below assessed value after being on the market for over 400 days. It is no comfort to these landowners that your article states that “instances of direct monetary loss are still inconclusive.”

How many other applications are there like ours, where we were told by Saanich where we had to build, even though three different registered professional biologists indicated in their reports that alternative locations would have been better suited to build from an environmental perspective?

While we agree there are properties where the EDPA may not impact property values, we must take into account other factors that are driving market prices such as the current high-demand real estate market, the favourable exchange rate of the U.S. dollar for foreign purchasers, historically low interest rates, and highest and best use properties. Of the latter, this would include newer houses that fully cover buildable areas within a lot, properties where there is only an EDPA buffer, or a small portion of EDPA on them, or simply do not require a permit of any kind.

If, however, someone wishes to buy a property within the EDPA where they plan to replace the existing home, or add another structure, even if no natural environment remains, they may be subjected to unreasonable requirements, restrictions and costs…which is exactly what happened to us.

Chris and Charmaine Phillips

Saanich

 

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Mysterious Brazilian honey barrel appears at Saanich intersection

Barrel spotted on West Saanich Road part of intersection construction project, district says

Lost dog reunited with family three months after going missing along Juan de Fuca trail

‘The poor thing was skin and bones,’ says one of the Sooke rescuers

Victoria family donates 878 falafel wraps to support Beirut blast victims

Wrap and Roll pulls in $20,500 during weekend fundraiser

Sidney joins federal government in Reay Creek improvements

Coun. Chad Rintoul says contract to renovate Reay Creek dam makes him ‘nervous’

B.C. records 30-50 new COVID-19 cases a day over weekend, no new deaths

Many of those testing positive were identified by contact tracing for being linked to other confirmed infections

Over half of Americans oppose Trump tariff on Canadian aluminum: survey

The survey was conducted Aug. 7 to 9 among 1,513 Canadians and 1,003 Americans

Oh baby, what a birthday gift: $2.8M raised to help B.C. boy with rare disease

‘We are very thankful to everybody,’ Aryan Deol’s father says

‘Huckleberry’ the bear killed after B.C. residents admit to leaving garbage out for videos

North Shore Black Bear Society said it was local residents who created a ‘death sentence’ for bear

Police investigating after insults, expletives yelled at federal minister’s staff

A 90-second video circulating on social media appears to have been shot by the person who was yelling

Central Vancouver Island’s Green Mountain fire under full control

Fire fighters still monitoring site between Cowichan Lake and Nanaimo River

5 B.C. First Nations call out Canada for ‘discriminatory’ food fish practices

West Coast nations say government ignoring court-won right to chinook and coho

B.C. marine ecologist wants Canada to sink its teeth into shark protection

Gulf Islands scientist says top predator under shocking threat from human behaviour

Rent-relief program becomes new front in fight between Liberals, opposition

Opposition trying to draw parallels between decision to have Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. run program and the WE controversy

Most Read